Inkstone
    May
    18
    2018
    May
    18
    2018
    Chinese firm hits back at $1 billion lawsuit filed by Avengers creator Stan Lee
    Chinese firm hits back at $1 billion lawsuit filed by Avengers creator Stan Lee
    BUSINESS

    Chinese firm hits back at $1 billion lawsuit filed by Avengers creator Stan Lee

    Triangle 4
    Photo: AFP
    arrow left
    arrow right
    Subscribe to the Inkstone newsletter
    By registering you must agree to our T&Cs

    The Chinese entertainment firm which owns exclusive rights to Stan Lee’s image says that a lawsuit filed by the comics legend is “completely without merit.”

    Hong Kong-based firm Camsing International acquired POW! Entertainment – the company which Lee co-founded in 2001 – last year.

    “The notion that Mr. Lee did not knowingly grant POW! exclusive rights to his creative works or his identity is so preposterous that we have to wonder whether Mr. Lee is personally behind this lawsuit,” said a statement released by Camsing on Thursday.

    The Avengers creator is seeking $1 billion in damages from the company he co-founded, accusing its executives of tricking him into signing away his name rights before selling POW! to Camsing International.

    Lee alleges that POW! CEO Shane Duffy and co-founder Gill Champion duped him into giving the company exclusive rights to use his name and likeness in 2017, according to court documents filed to a Californian court on May 15.

    Subscribe to the Inkstone newsletter
    By registering you must agree to our T&Cs
    Group 27@1x

    The pair “conspired and agreed to broker a sham deal to sell POW! to a company in China,” according to Lee’s lawyer.

    Camsing International has defended itself, saying that Lee and his only daughter are still substantial shareholders in the company. The firm says that it is looking forward to presenting “overwhelming” evidence in court.

    The firm specializes in brand licensing, entertainment, marketing and promotion. It recorded a profit of $5.7 million in 2016/17 financial year. 

    Lee has been behind a range of beloved superhero characters, including the Avengers, Black Panther and Iron Man.
    Lee has been behind a range of beloved superhero characters, including the Avengers, Black Panther and Iron Man. Photo: Marvel via AP

    Blind and grieving

    Lee alleges that in 2017 he was duped into signing an agreement to grant POW! exclusive rights to use his name, image and likeness at the request of Duffy, Champion and his former business manager Jerardo Olivarez. Olivarez is being sued by Lee a separate lawsuit.

    Lee said he was under the impression that the document was actually granting non-exclusive rights. Lee’s lawyer said that the agreement was therefore fraudulent, suggesting that the document might have been swapped, or his signature was forged or lifted from another document.

    It was argued that the 95-year-old Lee, with an estimated worth of $50 million, was in no condition to sign the document.

    Lee’s advanced years have been overshadowed by troubles at home. In April, Hollywood Reporter reported that he had been abused by his daughter.
    Lee’s advanced years have been overshadowed by troubles at home. In April, Hollywood Reporter reported that he had been abused by his daughter.

    Lee cannot read without help. He was declared legally blind in 2015, four years after he was diagnosed with macular degeneration. Around that time, his wife, to whom he was married for almost seven decades, passed away.

    The suit also claimed that POW! also took control of Lee’s social media accounts, including Facebook and Twitter, without his consent.

    The complaint also alleges that Duffy and Champion would have stood gain financially if a deal between POW! and Chinese firm Camsing went through, which it did in 2017.

    Duffy is now the vice president of Camsing Global, an affiliate of Camsing International.

    Grace Tsoi
    arrow rightarrow right
    Grace is a senior multimedia producer at Inkstone. She was previously a senior producer for BBC Chinese.
    Grace Tsoi
    arrow rightarrow right
    Grace is a senior multimedia producer at Inkstone. She was previously a senior producer for BBC Chinese.
    arrow right
      Rotate the screen
      Please rotate for best experience.
      Your privacy is important. We wish to inform you what data we collect from you and how we process such data. Our Privacy Notice aims to comply with all relevant data privacy and protection laws. You should read the Privacy Notice in full here.